Why review the estimate first
Appraisal takes time and costs money for both sides. Before you invoke it, you should know whether the gap between the insurer’s estimate and the real cost of repair is large enough to justify the process – and which items drive it. A careful estimate review answers those questions.
What we check
- Scope: missing rooms, components or trades; quantities that don’t match measurements; items listed as repair that need replacement.
- Pricing: unit costs compared with current local pricing for your island, not a mainland average or an outdated price list.
- General Excise Tax: whether GET is included and calculated correctly for your county. Our guide to General Excise Tax and freight in estimates explains why this is often missed.
- Freight and access: ocean freight, inter-island barge charges and hard access on hillside or remote lots.
- Overhead and profit: whether a general contractor would reasonably be needed and how the policy treats O&P.
- Depreciation: how actual cash value was calculated, and what recoverable holdback should be paid once work is done.
- Code items: work your county will require that the estimate leaves out, and whether ordinance or law coverage applies.
Common Hawaii estimate problems
Many estimates are written by adjusters who fly in after a large event or who work from pricing built for other markets. Typical issues include:
- GET left off entirely or applied only to materials.
- No allowance for freight to neighbor islands or remote areas like Hana, lower Puna or Kau.
- Single-wall homes scoped as if they had drywall interiors.
- Metal roofs priced as partial repairs when matching panels are unavailable.
- Condo work priced without high-rise access costs or building restrictions.
- Depreciation applied to labor or applied too heavily to newer materials.
Tools you can use now
The claim gap and fee estimator gives a quick sense of whether the difference justifies appraisal, and the RCV, ACV and holdback calculator helps you understand depreciation.
What to send us
For the most useful review, send the full carrier estimate (not just the summary page), your declarations page and policy form, any photos you have, contractor bids if you obtained them, and the carrier’s letters explaining its position. The more complete the file, the more precise our findings can be.
After the review
If the review shows a meaningful gap, you may decide to send the findings to your adjuster and ask for reconsideration, or to demand appraisal under your policy. If you go to appraisal, we can serve as your appointed appraiser – see our appraisal clause representation page. If the problem is a coverage denial rather than pricing, we will tell you that a Hawaii attorney is the better next step.
Hawaii Insurance Appraiser reviews estimates for homeowners, condo owners, associations and commercial owners on Oahu, Maui, Kauai, the Big Island, Molokai and Lanai. We are independent, we are not public adjusters, and we do not promise any particular outcome. What we provide is a clear, honest read on the numbers.
Common questions
Do I have to hire you as my appraiser after an estimate review?
No. The review stands on its own, and you are free to use the findings however you choose.
Why is GET so often missing from insurance estimates?
Estimating software and adjusters from outside Hawaii may not apply the General Excise Tax correctly by default. It applies to most contractor work and should be accounted for.
What if the review shows only a small gap?
We will tell you honestly. If the difference does not justify the cost and time of appraisal, other options such as asking the adjuster to reconsider may make more sense.
