How to use the estimator
- Enter the carrier’s RCV total — the replacement cost figure before depreciation and the deductible come off.
- Enter your own RCV total from an itemized contractor or independent estimate.
- Slide the landing point. The three-scenario strip shows the net at 30%, 50% and 80% of the gap at the same time.
- Add costs on the basis your appraiser quoted — flat, percentage or hourly — plus travel and half of a realistic umpire fee.
Reading the three scenarios
Appraisal panels rarely adopt either side’s opening number in full. Line items backed by photos, measurements and current island pricing tend to survive; unsupported items tend to fall away. If appraisal only pays off at the 80% landing point, the file is fragile. If the 30% scenario is still comfortably positive, the dispute is more likely to be worth pursuing.
Island cost factors to keep in mind
- Travel. Inspections on Molokai, Lanai or a different island from your appraiser can add airfare and a rental car.
- Umpire availability. Some neighbor-island panels use an umpire from Oahu, which can affect scheduling and cost.
- Pricing basis. Both estimates should treat freight and general excise tax consistently, or the “gap” is partly an apples-to-oranges problem.
The default figures above are illustrative only. For the payment side of the claim — depreciation and holdback — use the RCV/ACV holdback calculator.
Questions about this tool
Is the projected award a prediction?
No. It is a planning scenario based on the numbers you enter. Real awards depend on documentation, the panel and the policy wording.
Who pays the umpire?
Most appraisal clauses split the umpire’s fee equally between you and the insurer, while each side pays its own appraiser. Check your policy’s wording.
